SEMINOLE COUNTY, FLORIDA  
COUNTY SERVICES BUILDING  
1101 EAST FIRST STREET  
SANFORD, FLORIDA  
Meeting Agenda - Final-revised  
Thursday, December 12, 2024  
1:30 PM  
BCC Chambers  
Code Enforcement Special Magistrate  
I.  
APPROVAL OF REVISED AGENDA  
HEARINGS  
II.  
III.  
1.  
NEW CASES  
24-68-CESM  
NATVARLAL V UMRIGAR  
1028 MARTEX DRIVE, APOPKA, FL 32703  
(Commission District 3)  
Tax Parcel ID # 18-21-29-522-0I00-0130  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Posted  
Violation:  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix “A”, Section 105.1:  
Construction without the required permits.  
2.  
24-69-CESM  
RONALD W MORAN - HEIR  
740 OLD LAKE HARNEY ROAD, GENEVA, FL 32732  
(Commission District 2)  
Tax Parcel ID # 22-20-32-300-016A-0000  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Certified Mail  
Violation:  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix “A”, Section 105.1:  
Construction without the required permits.  
3.  
24-70-CESM  
CINTIA GRIECO & JOHN SCAGLIONE  
710 WYNN DRIVE, SANFORD, FL 32773  
(Commission District 2)  
Tax Parcel ID # 13-20-30-502-0000-0960  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Posted  
Violation:  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix “A”, Section 105.1:  
Construction without the required permits.  
4.  
24-71-CESM  
MARYBETH & TYLER CARLSON  
161 ALDER AVENUE, ALTAMONTE SPRINGS, FL 32714  
(Commission District 3)  
Tax Parcel ID # 09-21-29-503-0000-0940  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Certified Mail  
Violation:  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix “A”, Section 105.1:  
Construction without the required permits.  
IV.  
LIEN REQUESTS  
5.  
20-43-CESM  
NINIVE V CASTILLO  
209 COLLINS DRIVE, SANFORD, FL 32773  
(Commission District 2)  
Tax Parcel ID # 14-20-30-501-0F00-0060  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Posted  
Violation:  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix “A”, Section 105.1:  
Construction without the required permits.  
This case was originally heard by the Special Magistrate on June 11, 2020, and an Order  
was issued giving the Respondent a compliance date of August 12, 2021.  
An Affidavit of Non-Compliance was filed by the Inspector after re-inspection on  
September 24, 2021.  
On November 4, 2021, an Order was issued extending the compliance date to February  
10, 2022 and waiving any accrued fines.  
On April 14, 2022 an Order was issued extending the compliance date to July 14, 2022  
and waiving any accrued fines.  
An Affidavit of Non-Compliance was filed by the Inspector after re-inspection on July 20,  
2022.  
On April 13, 2023 an Order was issued extending the compliance date to July 13, 2023.  
An Affidavit of Non-Compliance was filed by the Inspector after re-inspection on July 20,  
2023.  
On November 14, 2024 an Order was issued extending the compliance date to December  
11, 2024, with a meeting scheduled for December 12, 2024.  
The Administrative Costs to process this case for the Clerk total $674.90.  
The Administrative Costs to process this case for the Inspector total $768.58.  
The Administrative Costs to process this case for both the Clerk and Inspector total  
$1,443.48.  
RECOMMENDATION: The Special Magistrate Board issue an Order constituting a lien in the  
retroactively back to August 12, 2021 and continues to accrue until in compliance.  
6.  
22-77-CESM  
B&B LAND HOLDING LLC  
JAMES BETTS (Registered Agent)  
3468 E SR 436, APOPKA, FL 32703  
(Commission District 3)  
Tax Parcel ID # 18-21-29-501-0A00-001B  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Posted  
Violation:  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix “A”, Section 105.1:  
Construction without the required permits.  
This case was originally heard by the Special Magistrate on October 13, 2022, and an  
Order was issued giving the Respondent a compliance date of January 12, 2023 with a  
fine of $50.00 per day to continue to accrue for each day the violation continues or is  
repeated after January 12, 2023.  
An Affidavit of Non-Compliance was filed by the Inspector after re-inspection on January  
24, 2023.  
An Affidavit of Non-Compliance was filed by the Inspector after re-inspection on August  
6, 2024.  
On August 8, 2024, an Order was issued giving the Respondent a compliance date of  
November 13, 2024, with a meeting scheduled for November 14, 2024.  
On November 14, 2024 an Order was issued giving the Respondent a compliance date of  
December 11, 2024, with a meeting scheduled for December 12, 2024.  
The Administrative Costs to process this case for the Clerk totals $250.84.  
The Administrative Costs to process this case for the Inspector totals $915.87.  
The Administrative Costs to process this case for both the Inspector and Clerk totals  
$1,166.71.  
RECOMMENDATION: The Special Magistrate Board issue an Order constituting a lien  
retroactively back to January 12, 2023 and continues to accrue until in compliance.  
7.  
23-15-CESM  
RONALD GUZMAN & CIARA PUZDER  
3969 CENTERVILLE WAY, SANFORD, FL 32771  
(Commission District 5)  
Tax Parcel ID # 33-19-31-516-0000-1860  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Posted  
Violation:  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix “A”, Section 105.1:  
Construction without the required permits.  
This case was originally heard by the Special Magistrate on February 9, 2023 and an  
Order was issued giving the Respondent a compliance date of April 14, 2023.  
An Affidavit of Non-Compliance was filed by the Inspector after re-inspection on October  
4, 2024.  
On November 14, 2024 an Order was issued giving the Respondent a compliance date of  
December 11, 2024, with a meeting scheduled for December 12, 2024.  
An Affidavit of Compliance was filed by the Inspector after re-inspection on December  
11, 2024.  
The Administrative Costs to process this case for the Clerk total $222.35.  
The Administrative Costs to process this case for the Inspector total $781.97.  
The Administrative Costs to process this case for both the Clerk and Inspector total  
$1,004.32.  
RECOMMENDATION: The Special Magistrate Board issue an Order constituting a lien in the  
amount of $30,350.00 for 607 days of non-compliance from April 14, 2023, through and  
including December 10, 2024, at $50.00 per day.  
8.  
23-17-CESM  
ASSET MANAGEMENT SERVICES OF AMERICA LLC  
2323 TUSKAWILLA ROAD, OVIEDO, FL 32765  
(Commission District 1)  
Tax Parcel ID # 36-21-30-300-001B-0000  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Posted  
Violation:  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix “A”, Section 105.1:  
Construction without the required permits.  
This case was originally heard by the Special Magistrate on February 9, 2023, and an  
Order was issued giving the Respondent a compliance date of April 14, 2023.  
An Affidavit of non-compliance was filed after re-inspection on April 19, 2023.  
The Administrative cost to process this case for the Clerk total $67.69.  
The Administrative cost to process this case for the Inspector total $889.09  
The Administrative cost to process this case for both the Clerk and Inspector total  
$956.78.  
RECOMMENDATION: The Special Magistrate Board issue an Order constituting a lien  
retroactively back to April 14, 2023, and continues to accrue until in compliance.  
9.  
23-36-CESM  
PATRICK G & NICOLE MCCARTHY JR  
400 E HILLCREST STREET, ALTAMONTE SPRINGS, FL 32701  
(Commission District 3)  
Tax Parcel ID # 12-21-29-5BD-6400-0190  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Posted  
Violation:  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix “A”, Section 105.1:  
Construction without the required permits.  
This case was originally heard by the Special Magistrate on March 9, 2023, and an Order  
was issued giving the Respondent a compliance date of April 14, 2023.  
An Affidavit of Non-Compliance was filed by the Inspector after re-inspection on April  
18, 2023.  
An Affidavit of Compliance was filed by the Inspector after re-inspection on December  
11, 2024.  
The Administrative cost to process this case for the Clerk totals $68.19.  
The Administrative cost to process this case for the Inspector totals $648.07.  
The Administrative cost to process this case for both the Clerk and Inspector totals  
$716.26.  
RECOMMENDATION: The Special Magistrate Board issue an Order constituting a lien in the  
amount of $30,400.00 for 608 days of non-compliance from April 14, 2023, through and  
including December 11, 2024, at $50.00 per day.  
10.  
24-25-CESM  
AHMED & SAKINA NURMOHAMED  
846 ISLE POINT, SANFORD, FL 32771  
(Commission District 5)  
Tax Parcel ID # 20-19-30-520-0000-6890  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Certified Mail  
Violation  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix “A”, Section 105.1:  
Construction without the required permits.  
This case was originally heard by the Special Magistrate on April 11,2024, and an Order  
was issued giving the Respondents a compliance date of July 10, 2024, with a meeting  
scheduled of July 11, 2024.  
An Affidavit of Non-Compliance was filed by the Inspector after re-inspection on July 10,  
2024.  
On July 11, 2024, an Order was issued extending the compliance date to September 11,  
2024, with a meeting scheduled for September 12, 2024.  
On September 12, 2024, the Special Magistrate issued an Order giving the Respondent a  
compliance date of October 9, 2024, with a meeting scheduled for October 10, 2024.  
The October 10, 2024 meeting was cancelled due to weather conditions and the  
Respondent was continued to the December 12, 2024 meeting.  
The Administrative cost to process this case for the Clerk totals $232.10.  
The Administrative cost to process this case for the Inspector totals $447.22.  
The Administrative Costs to process this case to date for both the Clerk and Inspector  
totals $679.32.  
RECOMMENDATION: The Special Magistrate Board issue an Order constituting a lien  
retroactively back to July 10, 2024, and continues to accrue until in compliance.  
11.  
24-31-CESM  
CONFIDENTIAL PER STATE STATUTES  
SHADY LANE, GENEVA, FL 32732  
(Commission District 2)  
Tax Parcel ID # 32-19-32-501-0000-0200  
Code Enforcement Officer: Cara Hill  
Notice of Hearing: Posted  
Violation:  
Seminole County Land Development Code, Chapter 30, Part 17, Section 30.302 - Uses  
permitted in a RM-1 zone:  
Storage and accessory structures on a vacant parcel is not a permitted use in an rm-1 zoning  
district.  
This case was originally heard by the Special Magistrate on June 13, 2024, and an Order  
was issued giving the Respondent a compliance date of December 4, 2024, with a  
meeting scheduled for December 12, 2024.  
An Affidavit of Non-Compliance was filed by the Code Enforcement Officer after  
re-inspection on December 4, 2024.  
The Administrative cost to process this case for the Clerk totals $154.86.  
The Administrative cost to process this case for the Code Enforcement Officer totals  
$247.87.  
The Administrative cost to process this case for both the Clerk and Code Enforcement  
Officer totals $402.73.  
RECOMMENDATION: The Special Magistrate Board issue an Order constituting a lien  
retroactively back to December 4, 2024 and continues to accrue until in compliance.  
12.  
24-37-CESM  
JASON TURNER  
5725 NORTH ROAD, SANFORD, FL 32771  
(Commission District 5)  
Tax Parcel ID # 24-19-29-300-004D-0000  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Posted  
Violation:  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix “A”, Section 105.1:  
Construction without the required permits.  
This case was originally heard by the Special Magistrate on July 11, 2024 and an Order  
was issued giving the Respondent a compliance date of October 9, 2024 with a meeting  
scheduled for October 10, 2024.  
The October 10, 2024 meeting was cancelled due to weather conditions and the  
Respondent was continued to the December 12, 2024 meeting.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for the Clerk total $154.86.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for the Inspector total $781.97.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for both the Clerk and Inspector total  
$880.47.  
RECOMMENDATION: The Special Magistrate issue an Order constituting a lien retroactively  
back to October 9, 2024 and continues to accrue until in compliance.  
13.  
24-40-CESM  
REBECCA A WIGGINS  
1217 GAIL STREET, APOPKA, FL 32703  
(Commission District 3)  
Tax Parcel ID # 17-21-29-512-0000-0740  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Certified Mail  
Violation:  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix “A”, Section 105.1  
Construction without the required permits.  
This case was originally heard by the Special Magistrate on August 8, 2024 and an Order  
was issued giving the Respondent a compliance date of October 9, 2024, with a meeting  
scheduled for October 10, 2024.  
The October 10, 2024 meeting was cancelled due to weather conditions and the  
Respondent was continued to the December 12, 2024 meeting.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for the Clerk total $173.98.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for the Inspector total $781.97.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for both the Clerk and Inspector total  
$955.95.  
RECOMMENDATION: The Special Magistrate Board issue an Order constituting a lien in the  
retroactively back to October 9, 2024, and continues to accrue until in compliance.  
14.  
24-41-CESM  
J5 PROPERTIES 8650 LLC  
GARY ALLEN JENSEN (Registered Agent)  
1980 HOWELL BRANCH ROAD, WINTER PARK, FL 32792  
(Commission District 4)  
Tax Parcel ID # 33-21-30-300-021A-0000  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Posted  
Violation:  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix “A”, Section 105.1:  
Construction without the required permits.  
This case was originally heard by the Special Magistrate on July 11, 2024 and an Order  
was issued giving the Respondent a compliance date of October 9, 2024 with a meeting  
scheduled for October 10, 2024.  
The October 10, 2024 meeting was cancelled due to weather conditions and the  
Respondent was continued to the December 12, 2024 meeting.  
An Affidavit of Compliance was filed by the Inspector after re-inspection on December  
11, 2024.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for the Clerk total $164.61.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for the Inspector total $768.58.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for both the Clerk and Inspector total  
$933.19.  
RECOMMENDATION: The Special Magistrate Board issue an Order constituting a lien in the  
amount of $8,850.00 for 59 days of non-compliance from October 9, 2024, through and  
including December 6, 2024, at $150.00 per day.  
15.  
24-44-CESM  
JAMES & ALLEXANDER MOSER BARKER  
2843 ORANOLE WAY, APOPKA, FL 32703  
(Commission District 3)  
Tax Parcel ID # 19-21-29-501-0000-0400  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Posted  
Violation:  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix “A”, Section 105.1:  
Construction without the required permits.  
This case was originally heard by the Special Magistrate on August 8, 2024, and an  
Order was issued giving the Respondent a compliance date of October 9, 2024, with a  
meeting scheduled for October 10, 2024.  
The October 10, 2024 meeting was cancelled due to weather conditions and the  
Respondent was continued to the December 12, 2024 meeting.  
An Affidavit of Compliance was filed by the Inspector after re-inspection on October 29,  
2024.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for the Clerk total $193.48.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for the Inspector total $969.43.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for both the Clerk and Inspector total  
$1,162.91.  
RECOMMENDATION: The Special Magistrate Board issue an Order constituting a lien in the  
amount of $1,050.00 for 21 days of non-compliance from October 9, 2024, through and  
including October 29, 2024, at $50.00 per day.  
16.  
24-46-CESM  
LAKE FOREST OWNER LLC  
CAPITOL CORPORATE SERVICES INC (Registered Agent)  
5433 W SR 46, SANFORD, FL 32771  
(Commission District 5)  
Tax Parcel ID # 30-19-30-300-002K-0000  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Personal Service  
Violation:  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix “A”, Section 105.1:  
Construction without the required permits.  
This case was originally heard by the Special Magistrate on August 8, 2024, and an  
Order was issued giving the Respondent a compliance date of October 9, 2024, with a  
meeting scheduled for October 10, 2024.  
The October 10, 2024 meeting was cancelled due to weather conditions and the  
Respondent was continued to the December 12, 2024 meeting.  
An Affidavit of Non-Compliance was filed by the Inspector after re-inspection on October  
2, 2024.  
An Affidavit of Compliance was filed by the Inspector after re-inspection on October 14,  
2024.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for the Clerk total $199.65.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for the Inspector total $848.92.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for both the Clerk and Inspector total  
$1,048.57.  
RECOMMENDATION: The Special Magistrate Board issue an Order constituting a lien in the  
amount of $1,200.00 for 6 days of non-compliance from October 9, 2024, through and  
including October 14, 2024, at $200.00 per day.  
17.  
24-52-CESM  
SERGIO R SALAZAR  
3572 JERICHO DRIVE, CASSELBERRY, FL 32707  
(Commission District 1)  
Tax Parcel ID # 23-21-30-502-0L00-0050  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Certified Mail  
Violation:  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix “A”, Section 105.1:  
Construction without the required permits.  
This case was originally heard by the Special Magistrate on August 8, 2024 and an Order  
was issued giving the Respondent a compliance date of October 9, 2024 with a meeting  
scheduled for October 10, 2024.  
The October 10, 2024 meeting was cancelled due to weather conditions and the  
Respondent was continued to the December 12, 2024 meeting.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for the Clerk total $154.86.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for the Inspector total $915.87.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for both the Clerk and Inspector total  
$1,070.73.  
RECOMMENDATION: The Special Magistrate Board issue an Order constituting a lien  
retroactively back to October 9, 2024, and continuing to accrue until in compliance.  
18.  
24-53-CESM  
BAF ASSETS 3 LLC  
THE PRENTICE-HALL CORP SYSTEM, INC (Registered Agent)  
CORPORATION SERVICE COMPANY (Registered Agent)  
3314 CURTIS DRIVE, APOPKA, FL 32703  
(Commission 3)  
Tax Parcel ID # 18-21-29-300-013B-0000  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Posted  
Violation:  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix “A”, Section 105.1:  
Construction without the required permits.  
This case was originally heard by the Special Magistrate on September 12, 2024, and an  
Order was issued giving the Respondent a compliance date of November 13, 2024, with  
a meeting scheduled for November 14, 2024.  
On November 14, 2024 an Order was issued giving the Respondent a compliance date of  
December 11, 2024, with a meeting scheduled for December 12, 2024.  
The Administrative cost to process this case for the Clerk totals $199.81.  
The Administrative cost to process this case for the Inspector totals $682.66.  
The Administrative cost to process this case for both the Clerk and Inspector totals  
$882.47.  
RECOMMENDATION: The Special Magistrate Board issue an Order constituting a lien  
retroactively back to November 13, 2024, and continuing to accrue until in compliance.  
19.  
24-60-CESM  
ANABEL FERNANDEZ  
1982 LONGWOOD LAKE MARY ROAD, LONGWOOD, FL 32750  
(Commission District 4)  
Tax Parcel ID # 20-20-30-501-0P00-0140  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Certified Mail  
Violation:  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix “A”, Section 105.1:  
Construction without the required permits.  
This case was originally heard by the Special Magistrate on September 12, 2024 and an  
Order was issued giving the Respondent a compliance date of October 9, 2024, with a  
scheduled meeting on October 10, 2024.  
The October 10, 2024 meeting was cancelled due to weather conditions and the  
Respondent was continued to the December 12, 2024 meeting.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for the Clerk total $143.19.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for the Inspector total $527.56.  
The Administrative costs to process this case for both the Clerk and Inspector total  
$670.75.  
RECOMMENDATION: The Special Magistrate Board issue an Order constituting a lien  
retroactively back to October 9, 2024, and continues to accrue until in compliance.  
V.  
CASES NOT HEARD BY THE BOARD  
20.  
24-14-CESM  
NEW OWNER  
MICHELLE GARCIA  
2202 BARKWOOD COURT, LAKE MARY, FL 32746  
(Commission DISTRICT 4)  
Tax Parcel ID # 20-20-30-509-0000-0290  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Posted  
Violation:  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix A, section 105.1.  
Construction without the required permits.  
21.  
24-43-CESM  
CONTINUED  
WOLFRAM & MEGAN NOTHNAGEL  
220 FORREST DRIVE, SANFORD, FL 32773  
(Commission District 4)  
Tax Parcel ID # 04-20-30-501-0700-0320  
Inspector: Jason Rucker  
Notice of Hearing: Posted  
Violation:  
Seminole County Code Chapter 40, Appendix “A”, Section 105.1:  
Construction without the required permits.  
VI.  
APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES  
VII.  
CONFIRMATION DATE OF NEXT MEETING: JANUARY 9, 2025  
VIII. ADJOURN  
NOTE: PERSONS WITH DISABILITIES NEEDING ASSISTANCE TO PARTICIPATE IN ANY OF THESE  
PROCEEDINGS SHOULD CONTACT THE HUMAN RESOURCES DEPARTMENT ADA COORDINATOR 48  
HOURS IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING AT 407-665-7940.  
PERSONS ARE ADVISED THAT IF THEY DECIDE TO APPEAL ANY DECISIONS MADE AT THIS HEARING,  
THEY WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, AND FOR SUCH PURPOSE THEY MAY NEED TO  
ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS ARE MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES  
THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED, PER SECTION 286.0105,  
FLORIDA STATUTES.  
FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REGARDING THIS AGENDA, PLEASE CONTACT THE CODE  
ENFORCEMENT CLERK AT (407) 665-7403.